The Myers-Briggs Type Indicator is one of the most commonly used personality tests in the world. Administered by potential employers, government agencies and colleges, it is a valuable tool for learning in depth information about the makeup of a subject’s personality. After answering an extensive series of introspective questions, the subject can be placed into one of 16 discrete personality types.
Two of these types are ISTJ and ISFJ. They are both introverts whose approach to the world centers around practicality and organization. ISFJs rely heavily on their emotional intelligence while ISTJs favor a strictly logical approach. The question is, will the differences with these two personality types preclude them from forming a friendship? What about a romantic relationship?
Are ISTJs and ISFJs compatible enough to be in a romantic relationship?
Both ISTJs and ISFJs are introverted, sensing and judging, while their key difference is that an ISTJ uses thinking and logic to make decisions whereas an ISFJ uses feelings and emotions. If they are willing to work with each other to overcome these differences, their relationship can thrive.
Reliable, hard working and loyal, ISTJs are introverts who specialize in planning and organization. They are no-nonsense achievers who use their skills to create logistical systems for maximum output. They are intellectual, detail-oriented and will generally prefer traditional methods over something new and modern. Some may feel that they seem detached because of their unemotional decision making style.
4 Characteristics of ISTJs
- They have a procedure for everything they do.
- They are comfortable with making decisions as long as they’ve had adequate time to study the facts.
- They are painfully honest and blunt — which may unintentionally hurt people’s feelings.
- They can work on teams if necessary but would prefer to work alone.
Above all else, ISFJs want everyone to be happy. They are naturally empathic — they can feel if there’s disharmony in any situation. Using their practical skills for organization, they seek to make order out of chaos and make people’s lives better. They care deeply for others, sometimes to the detriment of themselves. Even though they are introverts, they’re extremely people-oriented.
4 Characteristics of ISFJs
- They love to contribute to a community.
- They tend to be creatures of habit — change will often make them uneasy.
- They tend to be more comfortable in the background rather than on center stage.
- They are conscientious and hardworking.
Because of their many commonalities, the likelihood of an ISTJ and an ISFJ being a good match for each other seems to be high.
4 Reasons ISTJs and ISFJs would romantically mesh well together
- Both are logical, practical and have a strong sense of duty to others.
- Both personalities value traditional ways of doing things.
- They both like schedules, plans and neatly organized spaces.
- Both are looking for a long-term, committed relationship.
Regardless of their similarities, however, their logic versus emotional approach to the world could cause friction in a relationship.
4 Reasons ISTJs and ISFJs might have problems in a romantic relationship
- An ISFJ may view the ISTJ as being overly critical while the ISTJ may think the ISFJ is being too sensitive.
- ISFJs nurture and take care of people. The ISTJ, however, may not want to be taken care of.
- ISFJs show a lot of affection, much more than an ISTJ might be comfortable with. This discomfort could make the ISFJ feel rejected.
- ISFJs are more people-oriented than ISTJs and this could become an issue.
Romance / Love / Sex
There is no reason why ISTJs and ISFJs can’t be in a romantic relationship. What if the stakes are higher? Can these two personalities have a long-lasting love?
They certainly can. Both personalities believe in the tradition of love and marriage. They both hope to find a special person to spend their life with. When that happens, they will do whatever it takes to make that relationship work.
ISTJs may not seem like romantics at heart but in their own way, they are.
4 Ways an ISTJ might approach love
- They do not enjoy casual dating or frivolous relationships. They want a serious relationship that will last.
- When they find the right person and make a commitment, they will work hard to make sure that relationship succeeds.
- They get joy and satisfaction out of being the provider in a love relationship.
- They value tradition and stability and may tend to be more conservative than others when making relationship decisions.
ISFJs tend to behave more like traditional romantics than do ISTJs. They are emotional and caring and very attentive to their partners. In a relationship with an ISTJ, the ISFJ is likely to provide enough emotion for the both of them.
4 Ways an ISFJ might approach love
- They are not the type to “play the field” or have casual flings. ISFJs prefer a committed relationship.
- They love the emotional aspect of romance. They enjoy physical affection but may be hesitant and shy at first.
- For them, a sexual relationship is all about forming a deep connection to a committed partner.
- They can be rather conservative and traditional about sex.
If an ISTJ and an ISFJ are in love, there are many reasons why they might mesh well in a relationship:
- They both take a commitment very seriously and will do whatever they can to make it work.
- They are both happy to live by scheduled routines.
- They both generally feel the same way about sex — that it should be a private, intimate experience to express physical desire and emotional intimacy.
Because ISTJs and ISFJs have such a different approach regarding emotions, however, there may be problems:
- ISTJs may have a tendency to be stubborn and not listen to well-meaning suggestions from their ISFJ partner.
- For an ISFJ, relationships are all about intimacy. An ISTJ might have difficulty being emotionally available, let alone able to offer the kind of intimacy craved by an ISFJ.
- Both personality types tend to shy away from conflict, meaning they could each bottle up emotions and build up resentments.
Role of Gender
Some ISTJs and ISFJs conform to society’s traditional gender roles while others do not.
Pragmatism, professional drive and non-emotional logic are characteristics typically considered more masculine than feminine. ISTJ males, therefore, usually come closer to matching society’s expectations than do female ISTJs.
While male ISTJs might not seek leadership positions, they are comfortable leading others if the situation requires it. They are intensely logical, rarely bothering with emotional considerations or with how their decisions will affect other people’s feelings. They do have emotions, however, but may struggle to access them.
4 Characteristics of male ISTJs
- They do not have a fragile ego and don’t need titles or leadership roles to feel fulfilled.
- They show love by providing financially for their family and loved ones.
- They value tradition and may have what some consider to be old-fashioned views of male and female roles.
- They are reserved by nature but are actually deep feeling people.
ISTJ females often struggle because they are so different from the stereotypical idea of a woman. They are logical, rational and practical. They are not emotional and may have a hard time being empathetic to others. They love their family and friends but being nurturing does not always come easily to them.
4 Characteristics of female ISTJs
- Their tireless work ethic and pursuit of professional accomplishment can intimidate others.
- They value both personal and professional commitments.
- They are straightforward talkers and may unintentionally hurt people’s feelings with their bluntness.
- Even though they are confident, they may still defer to a male in some situations if they consider it to be traditionally appropriate.
Both male and female ISFJs rely very heavily on their intuition and emotions. Males, then, are often viewed as being different from other males while ISFJ females are more often considered in-tune with their gender role expectations.
ISFJ males are emotional, nurturing and relatively low-key. Their priority is to bring harmony and positivity to any environment they’re in. They tend to have few characteristics associated with being a typical “man’s man” and thus can sometimes be socially misunderstood by both sexes.
4 Characteristics of male ISFJs
- They are very empathetic and will go out of their way to make someone who is hurting feel better.
- Their compassion can sometimes incorrectly be viewed as fake or too good to be true by the more cynical personalities.
- They may seem more submissive than other males, which can make them a target of bullying.
- They tend to have a strong connection to their families.
Female ISFJs walk into a room and immediately get a sense of who needs a hug. They don’t hesitate to offer one, either. They are emotionally in-tune with others, naturally nurturing and yet very intelligent and practical. In some ways, they embody much of what a traditional woman is supposed to be.
4 Characteristics of female ISFJs
- They will tend to put the happiness of others before more logical considerations.
- They value the role of tradition and don’t necessarily like change.
- They put others first and need to remember to take adequate alone time to recharge.
- They spend so much time offering support to others, they need to remember to reach out themselves when they need something.
Possible relationship scenarios between ISTJ males and ISFJ females
- An ISTJ male might think he’s being reasonable by offering a blunt critique of the dinner his ISFJ girlfriend made for him as a surprise. He might be the one surprised by her tears and emotional reaction, not understanding why she’s so upset when he was just being honest.
- After a difficult day at work for an ISTJ male, his ISFJ girlfriend might ask over and over again how he’s feeling and if there is anything she can do to help him. This would only exhaust the ISTJ because he wants to be left alone, not nurtured.
Possible relationship scenarios between ISTJ females and ISFJ males
- The ISTJ female has always wanted to get more in touch with her emotional side. She knows she has a tendency to dismiss other people’s feelings. Luckily, her ISFJ boyfriend understands this and carefully explains to her why feelings matter and how she can choose her words carefully to avoid hurting other people.
- An ISTJ female dating an ISFJ male will soon realize that they’re both satisfied never doing anything different. After a while, they may feel like they are falling into a rut because neither one is interested in changing things up. At some point, however, they realize that they should take a chance and do something new.
Even though ISTJs have a logical approach to the world and ISFJs have a feeling approach, they both can make loyal and supportive friends.
When an ISTJ is your friend, they will probably be a friend for life. They are very choosy about who their friends are and consequently it may take a while before they feel comfortable opening up and allowing someone in to their life.
3 Characteristics of ISTJ friendships
- They offer support in the form of advice and practical information.
- Even with friends, they are often uncomfortable sharing personal details of their lives.
- They are honest and straightforward — what you see is what you get.
If you’re looking for a gentle and caring friend, you won’t do much better than an ISFJ. They live for helping others be their best selves. They happily accept people for who they are, flaws and all. They should be wary, however, of giving too much of themselves to their friends.
3 Characteristics of ISFJ friendships
- Because they are so generous with their friends, some bad actors could take advantage.
- They tend to take on their friends’ problems as their own and become overburdened.
- As introverts, they understand other people’s need for space and alone time.
Can ISTJs and ISFJs be friends?
They can absolutely be friends but they will need to respect each other’s differences. If they can do that, they should have no problem being friends.
4 Reasons why ISTJs and ISFJs might mesh well together
- They both are likely to have small circles of friends and probably won’t pressure the other to be involved with them unless they wanted to.
- Neither one will expect the other to be overly social and go to parties.
- Personal boundaries will be respected by both personalities.
- Both have a practical and logical approach to life.
4 Reasons why there might be potential problems in ISTJ an ISFJ friendship
- An ISTJ’s straight forward honesty is so different from the ISFJ’s emotional outreach. This could create friction in the friendship.
- Both are planners — it may be hard to fit each other into their schedules.
- The ISTJ may feel smothered by the ISFJ. The ISFJ may feel uncared for by the ISTJ.
- They both hate conflict and may be reluctant to deal with problems in the relationship.